Industry work on rare diseases continues to bear fruit
The setbacks suffered by BioMarin, PTC Therapeutics and Sarepta in muscular dystrophy in recent months have not diminished the industry’s keenness to work in rare diseases. Indeed, this space, loosely defined as life-threatening, non-cancer orphan indications that require chronic treatment, remains one of the bright spots for the biotech industry.
The exclusivity advantages and pricing power possible for companies that manage to develop orphan drugs give them favourable marketing economics, making for highly profitable products even if sales do not hit multi-blockbuster levels (see tables below). This is most evident at its most extreme, where there is an absence of payer pushback despite the very high prices of ultra-orphan conditions versus the charged rhetoric in not-so-rare therapy areas like hepatitis C.
The rare disease space has recently seen the launch of three high-profile products (Alexion’s twin approval highlights industry’s love of orphans, June 26, 2015). These are Orkambi for cystic fibrosis from Vertex, Alexion's Strensiq for hyperphosphatasia and Kanuma for lysosomal acid lipase deficiency.
All three are set to feature in the top 25 rare disease drugs by 2020, and indeed Orkambi looks set to reach second place in this league table with sales of just over $5bn, a shade under Alexion’s Soliris. EvaluatePharma consensus forecast for Soliris, which generated revenues of $2.6bn last year, suggests that sales will more than double over the next four years to $5.6bn.
|Top 25 rare disease products in 2020|
|Product||Company||Indication(s)||2020 sales ($)|
|Soliris||Alexion Pharmaceuticals||PNH, aHUS||5,600|
|Orkambi||Vertex Pharmaceuticals||cystic fibrosis, F508del mutation||5,030|
|NovoSeven||Novo Nordisk||haemophilia A||1,600|
|Kalydeco||Vertex Pharmaceuticals||Cystic fibrosis||1,054|
|Exjade||Novartis||iron overload, thalassemia||683|
|Prolastin-C||Grifols||AAT congenital deficiency||675|
|Kanuma||Alexion Pharmaceuticals||Liposomal acid lipase deficiency||670|
Much of the Soliris growth is expected to come from new indications, based on phase III studies that are expected to report over the next year. The outcome of the Regain trial in generalised myasthenia gravis is due imminently, and results from Protect in delayed graft function and Prevent in neuromyelitis optica should come later in the year or in early 2017. Analysts at Leerink see Soliris sales rising further to $7.5bn by 2025 if results are positive.
EP Vantage’s review suggests that a total of 11 rare disease products could achieve sales of $1bn or more by 2020, up from five currently. The top 25 has representation from both pharma and biotech sides of the industry with Sanofi, Novartis, Alexion and Shire, once it has completed its merger with Baxalta, each having three products, and Vertex and Roche represented with two each.
These top 25 rare disease products will have combined sales of $34.5bn by 2020, around double their 2014 collective figure, representing compounded growth of 17% over the next four years, a level that is unlikely to be matched elsewhere in the pharma industry.
By 2020 there could also have been some new entrants from products that are currently in late R&D. Ranked by consensus sales this table is currently topped by PTC’s Translarna for Duchenne muscular dystrophy, although this is likely to change, given its recent regulatory setback.
This leaves GW Pharmaceuticals’ Epidiolex as the top R&D rare disease asset. This is awaiting the outcome of four phase III trials in the difficult-to-treat childhood epilepsies Dravet and Lennox-Gastaut syndromes, with the first of these, in Dravet, expected to render results later this month.
|Top 10 rare disease R&D projects by forecast 2020 sales|
|Product||Company||Indication(s)||2020 sales ($)||Status|
|Translarna||PTC Therapeutics||Duchenne muscular dystrophy||850||Marketed (ex-US)|
|Epidiolex||GW Pharmaceuticals||Lennox-Gastaut Syndome, Dravet Syndrome||721||Phase III|
|Eteplirsen||Sarepta Therapeutics||Duchenne muscular dystrophy||544||Filed|
|Patisiran||Alnylam Pharmaceuticals||amyloidosis||432||Phase III|
|OCR-002||Ocera Therapeutics||hepatic encephalopathy||369||Phase II|
|Pegvaliase||BioMarin Pharmaceutical||PKU||345||Phase III|
|SPK-RPE65||Spark Therapeutics||Leber's congenital amaurosis||326||Phase III|
Rare disease specialists are not completely immune to the pressures felt throughout the sector – Alexion's shares have eroded at a rate similar to all of its Nasdaq brethren – but since these agents represent a much smaller share of payers' overall budgets than a new cholesterol drug, for instance, they are less likely to be subject to discount demands.
If winter has indeed come for biopharma, companies like Alexion, Actelion and Vertex might be a comfortable place for investors to hunker down.