Biotech IPO market remains open but investors prove picky eaters

The biotech IPO market staggered onwards in the third quarter of the year, with 10 new issues reaching western exchanges and raising $525m, according to EvaluatePharma. Investor appetite for these propositions might have diminished significantly, but the market is far from closed.

As Crispr Therapeutics demonstrates, however, investor enthusiasm is easily tested in the current climate. The third high-profile gene editing company to go public had to trim its price and downsize its offer to get away, which just about managed to prevent a tumble when the shares opened for trading today.

In its original SEC filing Crispr said it wanted to raise $90m, but it has gradually whittled this down to $56m. It finally floated today at $14 a share after selling four million new shares – the range was previously pitched at $15-17 with 4.7 million shares. The stock opened above $15 today.

The post-IPO performance of rivals Editas Medicine and Intellia Therapeutics, which also went public this year, cannot have helped its case. These stocks are respectively 14% and 33% below their offer price. Crispr has raised half the amount of its predecessors, with concerns including IP protection and development timelines having taken the shine off this hot gene therapy approach for investors.

Still, Crispr is not included in the analysis above, which runs until the end of September. This includes companies developing human therapeutics only – medtech and diagnostics are excluded.

Similar amounts were raised each quarter so far in 2016, and were noticeably below the levels seen in the past two years. Many investors have taken cash out of this high-risk sector since the beginning of 2016, exiting with the deflating biotech bubble, amid ongoing concerns about drug pricing.

It is also notable that of the 10 flotations identified this quarter, four occurred in Europe. With only six flotations in the US, activity in this region matches the rate seen in the first quarter, in the wake of the Nasdaq Biotechnology Index crash in January.

As such, flotations need to pick up in the final quarter of the year for 2016 to reach 2013 levels. It seems more likely that the average amount raised will be a touch lower, as this year has seen a notable lack of big offerings. The exit of crossover funds, which help prop up substantial flotations, is one reason for this.

Biotech IPO market by year
Year No. of IPOs Amount raised ($bn) Avg. amount raised ($m) No. raising >$100m
9M 2016 34 1.78 52.3 2
2015 61 4.68 76.7 17
2014 87 6.30 72.4 18
2013 44 2.96 67.2 7
2012 16 0.93 58.2 2
2011 17 0.69 40.4 2

Next quarter could see at least one large offering: Myovant Sciences promises to be the biggest IPO of the year so far. The company has a novel GnRH receptor antagonist in mid-stage trials for uterine fibroids, endometriosis and prostate cancer and is seeking up to $195m to run three phase III studies. Relugolix was licensed from Takeda, which retained domestic rights – the Japanese pharma company will report pivotal data on the compound next year.

Still, the looming US presidential election provides a good reason for companies to pause financing plans – to avoid any market volatility – so the end of 2016 could easily see a drop-off in activity. The data this quarter show that many companies had to take haircuts to get away, perhaps providing even more reason to delay, in the hope of a return to more buoyant times.

As always, however, investor appetite is also heavily influenced by the performance of recent IPOs, and on this measure the class of 2016 is struggling. Although there are success stories – like Novan and AC Immune in the table below – there are also a number of disappointments. Alongside the poorly performing Crispr stocks, the likes of Aeglea Biotherapeutics and Oncobiologics remain well below their offer prices.

They have not been helped by deflated biotech indices, of course. Should these struggle to hold up in the coming months – and there are plenty of potential events to trigger a downturn – the IPO market of 2017 could start to look even sorrier.

Q3 biotech IPOs on Western exchanges (all Nasdaq unless stated)
Company Amount raised ($m) Offering price Discount/ premium First-day close 2016 Q3 chg since float 
Synact Pharma* 9 SEK6.4 - (19%) 11%
GenSight Biologics^ 44 €8.00 (6%) 2% 11%
Pharnext^ 34 €10.82 (10%) (5%) (4%)
Audentes Therapeutics 75 $15.00 0% 1% 19%
Kadmon 75 $12.00 (33%) (19%) (39%)
Gemphire Therapeutics 30 $10.00 (17%) (8%) 9%
Protagonist Therapeutics 90 $12.00 0% (3%) 76%
Novan Therapeutics 52 $11.00 (8%) 65% 83%
AC Immune 66 $11.00 (8%) 42% 50%
NOXXON Pharma^ 49 €21.34 - 1% 1%
*AktieTorget; ^Euronext.

To contact the writer of this story email Amy Brown in London at [email protected] or follow @ByAmyBrown on Twitter

Share This Article