Glaxosmithkline’s desire to catch up in oncology helped persuade the company to part with a $625m up-front fee earlier this week for Iteos's anti-Tigit MAb EOS-448, a huge amount to pay for a single phase 1 project. Proving that cancer is still an incredibly competitive space, Bristol Myers Squibb followed today with a deal over an early-stage Eisai asset, involving $650m in initial fees.
Phase 1 projects rarely go for such sums, a search of deals database BiosciDB shows, with only one single-asset transaction commanding a bigger up-front fee: Daiichi Sankyo’s Trop2 antibody-drug conjugate DS-1062, which cost Astrazeneca $1bn on signing. That was one of several huge early-stage transactions struck in 2020, a year that saw $3.6bn in up fronts change hands in deals over phase 1 assets.
The graph below shows that 2020 was a clear outlier, the culmination of a big jump in deal activity over the back half of the last decade. The BiosciDB data point to an uptick in both the volume of licensing deals concerning phase 1 assets and the sums involved. Today's Bristol and Eisai tie-up means that 2021 is already on track to be another big year.
This analysis only includes deals that contained a disclosed up-front element.
Surging valuations in oncology have been a big driver behind these numbers. When looking at the top five up-front fees, below, all but one concerns a cancer asset. Today's deal over Eisai's folate receptor α ADC knocked another Bristol deal out of fifth place: last year's licensing of Dragonfly's IL-12 project DF6002, for $475 up front.
It is important to note that these five transactions are not entirely comparable; Abbvie's deal, on top of the three named projects, also involved a discovery research collaboration with Genmab. But this makes the sums paid for single projects all the more remarkable.
An interesting aside is that Biogen's deal with Denali is the last of three substantial transactions that the big biotech struck in the last two years that is still standing. The other two, the acquisition of Nightstar and licensing of Sage’s depression assets, all but collapsed this week.
A big price tag does not improve a project’s chance of success, of course, and all the deals below have some time to run before judgement can be made.
|Big early-stage bets|
|Buyer||Partner||Lead project(s)||Up-front fee ($m)||Deal date|
|Astrazeneca||Daiichi Sankyo||DS-1062 (Trop2 targeted ADC for cancer)||1,000||Jul 2020|
|Abbvie||Genmab||Epcoritamab, DuoHexaBody-CD37 and DuoBody-CD3x5T4 (cancer bispecifics)||750||Jun 2020|
|Bristol Myers Squibb||Eisai||MORAb-202 (folate receptor α targeted ADC for cancer)||650||Jun 2021|
|Glaxosmithkline||Iteos||EOS-448 (Anti-Tigit MAb)||625||Jun 2021|
|Biogen||Denali||DNL151 (LRRK2 inhibitor for Parkinson's, plus options over other projects)||560||Aug 2020|
BiosciDB is owned by Evaluate Ltd.